17 Comments
User's avatar
Amanda V Shane's avatar

I remember the days of used bookstore shopping where I would pick books by the spine. Lol. I’m not kidding. 😅 If the title intrigued me, I would buy it, read it, and if I hated it, I had an “Oh well, better luck next time” attitude about it. I do read reviews, but usually after I’ve read the book for the reasons you talked about.

Expand full comment
Roni Loren's avatar

Love that you would just roll the dice on a spine! Lol. How fun!

Expand full comment
Amanda V Shane's avatar

I actually found a lot of good books that way. 😁

Expand full comment
Karen R's avatar

A good quarter of the books I buy these days are pre-orders and there are no reviews, which saves me the trouble of angsting over them. :) But when I *do* read reviews, I'm mostly looking for consistency. If all the 1 star reviews say "Oh god the typos why why" I take that into account, but if they're all over the map with what the reviewers didn't like, I assume it's just a matter of taste. Plus almost all books these days let you read an excerpt, and between that and the blurbs, I can usually tell if I'm going to like it. And if I don't, well, life is pain. There will always be another book to try later.

Expand full comment
Roni Loren's avatar

Yes, I think that's a good method of looking for consistency. If I see a book has a 3.5 or lower average, I look to the reviews because usually that means there was some consistent issue people didn't like.

Expand full comment
Denise's avatar

It's been a while since I've watched Reality Bites. I am Gen X.

I don't pay a lot of attention to reviews. I write too many of them to be objective. (I only leave positive reviews.)

Expand full comment
Roni Loren's avatar

I can imagine if you're regularly writing reviews, you don't want to read others because that could also influence yours.

Expand full comment
T. Rosado's avatar

I'm big on researching books and authors, but I have the memory of an elephant and if I read a spoiler, it will never be forgotten. I HATE spoilers. I usually do a quick scan of the ratings from trusted reader friends versus reading the reviews. Reviews are for when I'm still undecided and might need to dig a little deeper, but it's rare. I've learned that sometimes those 3.5-star average books can be my 5-star and just have to go with my gut. It has served me well since my tastes can be a bit eclectic. I think it's also why I enjoy your recs.

I'll occasionally read reviews after I've read the book, but I refuse to acknowledge any reviewers who make statements like the 1-star review you shared. Those are people who don't understand subjectivity and how offensive their statements can be to other readers, let alone the author. How can I trust their opinion if they've already offended me?

Expand full comment
Roni Loren's avatar

I agree that sometimes those books with the lower reviews end up being ones I really liked. On the flip side, many times ones with universally high reviews end up not working for me, lol. Guess we're the weirdos! lol

Expand full comment
Rebecca Faith Heyman's avatar

Pre-ordered Nightingale -- love that you're doing this! Also, the Reality Bites soundtrack will always be a favorite. It's aged beautifully and is such a MOOD.

Expand full comment
Roni Loren's avatar

Thank you for pre-ordering! <3 And you're right, it's a total mood soundtrack.

Expand full comment
Meridith S's avatar

As a fellow Gen Xer, Reality Bites is one of my all time faves! I’ve watched at least a dozen time, and always have to pause when Troy & Lelaina finally kiss in the kitchen. Seriously, he should have won an Oscar just for his facial expression—joy & pain & “oh god I’m going to f this up”

Expand full comment
Roni Loren's avatar

Such a great look! <3

Expand full comment
Sandy Williams's avatar

I don't remember watching this movie but your description of that kiss makes me need to!

Expand full comment
Beverly L's avatar

That kiss is in my top 3 movie kisses. His eyes just melt me.

Expand full comment
Megan Burton's avatar

Reality Bites is one of my favorite movies of all time! I adore it with all my 90s kid's soul.😍

Expand full comment
Roni Loren's avatar

<3

Expand full comment